tree_and_leaf: Dark haired woman, pen and ink drawing with watercolour.  Looks a bit like Harriet Vane. (Harriet)
tree_and_leaf ([personal profile] tree_and_leaf) wrote in [personal profile] nineveh_uk 2014-02-15 09:38 am (UTC)

Ah - that makes sense (and I take it back, it is at least slightly interesting!) A Catholic background and being interested in faith, but not a practicing Anglican would perhaps explain why she put the detail in, but in a hamfisted way.

Anglo-Catholic Bunter annoys me because I feel it's there solely to set up Helen being annoyed. It's so unnecessary

Indeed. All I can remember that's ever said about Bunter's religious position is when Peter and Miss Murchison are discussing the reliability of the housekeeper's evidence, and Peter says that Bunter, who has been buttering her up and accompanying her to chapel, believes her to be sincerely pious, honest and sensible. Miss Murchison wonders if he's being biased by her chapel-going; Peter says something like "If you'd seen Bunter in his off-duty hours, you'd realise the sight of a hymn-book is about as softening to his heart as whisky to an Anglo-Indian colonel's liver." It's an odd metaphor, but all the same, interpreting this to mean that Bunter spent his off-duty hours as at All Saint's Margaret Street or some similar spiky shrine strikes me as a bit of a stretch...

Post a comment in response:

If you don't have an account you can create one now.
HTML doesn't work in the subject.
More info about formatting